⚡Why Traditional Marketing Fails for Musicians + what to do instead


PROFITABLE MUSICIAN WEEKLY NEWSLETTER

February 12, 2025

Welcome to Profitable Musician, your guide to growing your fanbase, increasing your income and becoming more profitable. Shared with ~16,000+ readers every Wednesday. Was this forwarded to you? Subscribe here so you don't miss the next one.


Hey there, Profitable Musicians!

Have you ever attended a marketing workshop that you were super excited about...

and then left after investing several hours, feeling like it was a huge waste of time?

I've had this happen too many times. Why?

Because marketing our music is a whole different animal from traditional marketing of a product or a service.

I decided it's time to bring up this "elephant in the room" that I feel like people who teach marketing try to sweep under the rug.

In this issue

🥽Deep Dive: ⚡Why Traditional Marketing Fails for Musicians + what to do instead


🛠️Fan Attraction Workshop TOMORROW


📰Need-To-Know Music Industry News & Tips


🎧Should You Enter Yet Another Music Contest?


📻Playlist-Worthy Music

Once you accept that musicians need to take an uncommon marketing path, you're probably thinking, "OK, what DO I do then?"

That's what I'm covering in this week's workshop. Click here to grab your spot and I'll see you there tomorrow.

Always in your corner,
<3 Bree

produced in partnership with:

The Counterintuitive Way To Attract More Fans Without Feeling Pushy or Desperate

Join me tomorrow for this free workshop where I'm covering my Fan Attraction Formula to magnetically PULL fans toward your music instead of feeling like you're being pushy or begging for attention.

NEEd-to-know

Music Industry News & Tips

Click worthy

Get In The Mood For Love

Our Women of Substance "Love Songs For Valentines" Spotify Playlist Is Out

Get in the mood for Valentines Day by supporting these amazing female artists. Listen while you work, drive, etc. this week. Hit the "+" to add it to your library.

TODAY'S Profitable DEEP DIVE

⚡Why Traditional Marketing Fails for Musicians + what to do instead

Ever feel like every marketing guru is speaking a language completely foreign to musicians?

“Find a problem. Offer a solution.”
“Highlight the benefits of your product.”

And you’re sitting there thinking, But my music isn’t a product—it’s a piece of my soul.

And it doesn't solve a problem in the traditional sense - at least not a problem they know they have.

I get it. Most marketing advice just doesn’t click for musicians. Why? Because music isn’t toothpaste. It’s not a weight-loss program. It’s something far deeper, more personal, and way harder to define.

I feel like no one talks about this elephant in the room.

So I'm just gonna say it:

Musicians need to throw out the traditional marketing playbook and take a completely different approach.

The Problem-Solving Paradox: Music Heals in Ways We Can’t Always Explain

Business 101 tells us that successful products solve a problem. A meal delivery service saves time. A productivity app helps you get more done.

But music? It doesn’t fix a problem in the same way… or does it?

Think about it. Music is emotional infrastructure. It’s the soundtrack to heartbreak, the fuel for a revolution, the anthem that lifts someone out of despair. Your songs aren’t just entertainment—they help people process emotions, feel seen, and make sense of their world.

Your music solves deeply human problems:

🎵 Emotional healing – Your ballad helps someone through a breakup.
🎵 Mental health support – Your song lifts someone from the weight of anxiety.
🎵 Perspective shifting – Your lyrics open someone’s eyes to a new way of thinking.
🎵 Community building – Your music brings people together, creating connection.
🎵 Cultural expression – Your sound represents something bigger than yourself.

The key? Stop thinking of your music as a product and start seeing it as an experience that people need—even if they don’t realize it yet.

The experience of actively listening to your music can be a salve that heals.

But you can't just use a problem-solution framework in your marketing that says that. I'll get to what you CAN use in a minute.

The Desire Dilemma: How to Market What Listeners Don’t Know They Need

Here’s the challenge: Listeners don’t wake up thinking, I need to find a new favorite artist today.

They don’t crave what they haven’t experienced yet. That’s why traditional marketing falls flat—your music isn’t something they can see or touch like a physical product.

So how do you make people want your music?

💡 You don’t market the song. You market the feeling the song gives them.

Picture this: A potential fan is scrolling through their feed, feeling lost, uninspired. Instead of just saying, “Hey, check out my new song!”—you speak directly to their experience.

You say:

"Ever feel like no one understands what you’re going through? I wrote this song for you."

Now, suddenly, they’re curious. They’re emotionally invested before they’ve even heard a single note.

The power of Personal Brand: Why YOU Are Your Best Marketing Strategy

Let’s be real—overly polished, corporate-style branding kills connection. Fans aren’t looking for perfection. They’re looking for real humans they can relate to.

Your personal brand isn’t just a marketing strategy—it’s the bridge between you and your future fans.

Think about the artists you love. It’s not just their music that draws you in—it’s their story, their personality, their quirks. Fans don’t just want songs. They want to feel like they’re part of something—your world, your journey, your why.

What makes you unforgettable?

🔥 Your life experiences – The things that shaped you, that give your music depth.
🌎 Your roots – How your hometown, culture, or upbringing influences your sound.
🎶 Your passions – The causes, ideas, and emotions that set your soul on fire.
🤓 Your quirks – The weird, wonderful things that make you you.
💔 Your struggles – The challenges you’ve faced, the lessons you’ve learned.

Your future fans are looking for connection in a world that feels more disconnected than ever.

They want to know:

  • What makes you tick?
  • What breaks your heart?
  • What makes you laugh until you cry?
  • What do you stand for?

When you share these pieces of yourself, something shifts. Fans stop seeing you as just another artist and start seeing you as someone who gets them. Someone they want to root for. Someone whose music isn’t just sound—but a feeling, a movement, a home.

Practical Ways to Build Your Personal Brand

✅ Be Consistently YOU – Your online presence should feel like an extension of who you are, not a persona you’re trying to maintain.
✅ Document the Journey – Share your highs, your lows, your creative process. Fans want to be part of it all.
✅ Show Behind-the-Scenes Moments – From songwriting to studio sessions to late-night lyric scribbles—invite people in.
✅ Engage Like a Human – Respond to comments and DMs with the same energy you’d give a friend, not a customer.
✅ Stand for Something – Don’t be afraid to share your values, your mission, your purpose. It’s what makes your music mean more.

Your New Marketing Mantra: Connection Over Promotion

If you take one thing from this, let it be this:

Stop trying to fit into traditional marketing boxes.

Your music is a living, breathing expression of human experience. Market the person behind the music, the story behind the song, the emotion behind the melody.

Because in the end, people don’t just want to hear your music.

They want to feel it.
They want to belong to it.
They want to be part of the world you’re creating.

And when you show up as your real, authentic self?

That’s when fans don’t just listen. They stay. 🎶✨

ON THE PODCAST

Bree delves into the benefits of winning awards, such as gaining legitimacy and credibility, and how these accolades can enhance your artist bio and introductions.

However, she also tackles the question of when to stop chasing awards and how to strategically choose which competitions to enter.

Playlist-Worthy TrackS

ARTIST: beth morris

Named one of the Fiercest performers WILL I AM has ever seen, compared to the likes of Amy Winehouse and Freddie Mercury. Beth Morris is turning industry heads. Her unforgettable vocal style and unapologetic honesty in sharing the truth through her music is what sets Beth Morris apart from the rest.

ARTIST: rachel goldie

Born and raised in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, Rachel Goldie had passion for poetry and music since childhood. Her songs reflect personal experiences and universal emotions, and she hopes listeners enjoy them as much as she enjoys creating them.

SONG #1

ARTIST

Beth Morris


SONG

I Love You I Miss You


artist
I Love You I Miss You
Beth Morris
PREVIEW
Spotify Logo
 

SONG #2

ARTIST

Rachel Goldie


SONG

My Valentine


artist
My valentine
Rachel Goldie
PREVIEW
Spotify Logo
 

Bree Noble

Say "Hello' on Instagram, Facebook, TikTok, Threads or BlueSky

When You're Ready, here are 3 ways we can help you become a more Profitable Musician:

Join Female Musician Academy (February training: "Create A Merch Line That Sells")

If you choose to Unsubscribe, it will remove you from updates on programs you've purchased. We won't be able to let you know when we're playing your music on the podcast, and we can't let you know about any calls for specific music, free training, awesome articles, new podcast episodes and tools for musicians, etc.
38396 Sierra Lakes Dr., Oakhurst, CA 93644

The Profitable Musician Newsletter

Whether you're a career artist, a passionate side hustler, or a hobby musician looking to fund your next project, The Profitable Musician Newsletter will help you become more profitable in just 3 minutes. Join 16,600+ musicians 3 times per week as we grow our fanbase, amplify our income & become more profitable together.

Read more from The Profitable Musician Newsletter

PROFITABLE MUSICIAN WEEKLY NEWSLETTER April 2, 2025 Welcome to Profitable Musician, your guide to growing your fanbase, increasing your income and becoming more profitable. Shared with ~16,000+ readers every Wednesday. Was this forwarded to you? Subscribe here so you don't miss the next one. Hey there, Profitable Musician! Before I jump into this week's content, I wanted to quickly mention that I'm offering my free Fan Attraction Formula workshop TODAY at noon ET. There's still time to...

PROFITABLE MUSICIAN: FEM FRIDAY EDITION March 28, 2025 Welcome to the Profitable Musician Newsletter, FEM Friday Edition. This Friday newsletter is created for Female Artists & Advocates, and focuses on our mission to amplify quality music by Female Artists & Female-Fronted Bands in all genres and help them build a thriving music career and solid business. If you'd like to unsubscribe from FEM Fridays but still receive our regular Wednesday Profitable Musician Newsletter, click here and we'll...

PROFITABLE MUSICIAN WEEKLY NEWSLETTER March 26, 2025 Welcome to Profitable Musician, your guide to growing your fanbase, increasing your income and becoming more profitable. Shared with ~16,000+ readers every Wednesday. Was this forwarded to you? Subscribe here so you don't miss the next one. Hey there, Profitable Musician! I've got some "real talk" for you today. I want to start by giving you a huge compliment, but then show you how that very thing I praise you for may be keeping you stuck...