Next-level Fanbase growth strategy (beyond email & social)


PROFITABLE MUSICIAN WEEKLY NEWSLETTER

October 14, 2026

Hey there, Profitable Musician!

If you’ve been reading my emails lately, you know how strongly I feel about staying connected with your fans through email.

Your email list is something you can take with you. You can reach out to people who’ve asked to hear from you without waiting for a social media algorithm to put your post in front of them. And when someone hits reply, you get to have a conversation.

Plus, you don't have to worry that suddenly that platform Gods will block you from your own community. Ask me how I know so much about this...I experienced it firsthand last August and have never gotten access reinstated to my previous Facebook.

But today I want to take you a level deeper.

There’s another kind of conversation you want to create space for an help facilitate: the one your fans have with each other.

I saw a perfect example just last week when I took my daughter to a SOMBR concert for her birthday.

There were thousands and thousands of people there, all enjoying the same music. But when my daughter found out that another girl in her choir had been at the concert, they suddenly had something more in common.

Now they’re having a DM conversation about how awesome the concert was and all the stand out moments they loved.

Their shared love of the music gave them a reason to connect beyond choir. In fact, they'd barely spoken before this. But now they have something to talk about.

Imagine that happening between your fans.

Someone shares which song got them through a difficult season, and another person responds because she’s been through something similar. Or fans who met at your last show start making plans to attend the next one together.

Your music becomes the reason people meet. Those friendships give them another reason to stay involved. And that translates into more fan engagement for you including more people attending concerts, buying merch and getting excited enough about what you do to share it and invite new people in.

That’s the next level of fan connection I want you to think about.

You’re probably already creating opportunities for people to connect with you. Where can they connect with each other?

My new favorite community platform, Heartbeat, gives you a place to facilitate those conversations.

Heartbeat brings community discussions and private messaging together with live events, courses and member payments. Your fans can find each other through a member directory and keep talking between the events you host.

For a musician, that could mean a paid fan community where you share early demos and host a monthly listening party. If you teach, you could offer a course with a community where students ask questions and encourage each other as they practice.

You can build an offer around what your people actually want and what you have time to deliver.

And yes, Patreon offers ways for fans to interact, including comments and community chats. The difference is that Heartbeat puts more tools for connecting members with each other at the center of the experience. Patreon currently doesn’t offer private messaging between members.

A Facebook group can generate conversations, too. But Facebook controls the platform, and losing access to your group could cut you off from the community you’ve worked to build.

With Heartbeat, you have a dedicated space under your own brand, with your colors and custom domain. You control the member experience without having to compete with everything else in a Facebook feed.

​Click here to try Heartbeat FREE for 14 days + use code PROFITABLEMUSICIAN for 20% off your first 3 months!

SIDE NOTE: Some of you may know that I use Circle for my community. So why am I recommending Heartbeat instead. Well, 2 reasons:

  1. Heartbeat did not exist when I started my community on Circle back in 2021.
  2. Heartbeat offers a pricing option that is more musician-friendly

Keep using email to invite your fans into your music and your life. Then consider whether a community could give them a reason to keep the conversation going together.

Always in your corner,
<3 Bree

P.S. Start by thinking about the conversation, before planning a whole membership. What would your fans enjoy talking about with someone who loves your music as much as they do? My daughter and her choir friend already had plenty to say. They just needed to find each other. Start your free 14-day trial here.​

You're reading the Profitable Musician, your guide to growing your fanbase, increasing your income and becoming more profitable. Shared with ~10,000+ readers every Wednesday. Was this forwarded to you? Subscribe here so you don't miss the next one.

CLICK WORTHY

Everything you need (at a musician-friendly price) to turn your fanbase into a community you own, can grow and monetize.

Bree Noble

Say "Hello' on Instagram, Facebook, TikTok, or Threads​

When You're Ready, here are 3 ways we can help you become a more Profitable Musician:

If you choose to Unsubscribe, it will remove you from updates on programs you've purchased. We won't be able to let you know when we're playing your music on the podcast, and we can't let you know about any calls for specific music, free training, awesome articles, new podcast episodes and tools for musicians, etc.
600 1st Ave, Ste 330 PMB 92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2246

The Profitable Musician Newsletter

Whether you're a career artist, a passionate side hustler, or a hobby musician looking to fund your next project, The Profitable Musician Newsletter will help you become more profitable in just 3 minutes. Join 16,600+ musicians 3 times per week as we grow our fanbase, amplify our income & become more profitable together.

Read more from The Profitable Musician Newsletter

PROFITABLE MUSICIAN: FEM FRIDAY EDITION October 2, 2026 Happy FEM Music Friday! Today I want to look at fan connection through two completely different lenses. Dopamine and Oxytocin. I’m not suggesting that we can reduce all human behavior to two brain chemicals. Neuroscience is obviously more complicated than that. But as a way of thinking about what we’ve been trained to value online versus what actually builds a relationship, I found the contrast really useful. Dopamine is closely...

PROFITABLE MUSICIAN WEEKLY NEWSLETTER September 30, 2026 Hey there, Profitable Musician! I'm going to borrow an economics term that I believe applies surprisingly well to what’s happening in music right now. A K-shaped economy is one where two groups that once seemed to be moving in roughly the same direction begin separating. One branch rises while the other falls away. I think music is developing its own version of that. For years, the internet kept lowering the barriers to releasing music....

PROFITABLE MUSICIAN: FEM FRIDAY EDITION September 25, 2026 Happy FEM Music Friday! Yes this is our FEM Friday email, usually sent to female artists and advocates only, but I'm sending it to everyone because this news is important. Meta (owner of Facebook and Instagram) dropped a BOMBSHELL on September 21...and the shot was heard around the world. We now have to PAY to put links in our posts on Facebook and Instagram! According to my sources, what this means is that Meta is allowing ZERO links...