Here is what the science says, in plain language:
Uncertainty lights up the brain. When there is a real chance to win, dopamine kicks in.
That uncertainty creates attention and energy, which is why lotteries and surprise reveals feel so compelling, even when the prize is small.
Gamification works in practice too. Game elements have been found to produce positive effects on motivation and behavior, especially when there is a mix of competition and collaboration. Think fans playing along with you and also pulling for each other.
And here is the best part for fan relationships. When someone wins once, they are more likely to try again and stay engaged the next time. It also breeds loyalty. You better believe once I won a prize I kept listening to that radio station!
And, I didn't keep listening so I could win again (although that was one motivation and benefit). But gratitude and reciprocity were also reasons I kept tuning in.
And when you showcase winners, you trigger social proof. People trust what their friends say far more than any ad. So a simple photo of a winner with you and their prize can ripple through their circle and beyond.
So how do we use all this at shows and online without it feeling cheesy or expensive?
At your show, add a quick, fun trivia moment with a real prize.
Keep it tight between songs. Ask a question about your career or about one of your idols that they are also likely to love.
Give away something you can hand over on the spot like a tee, a signed poster, or a small bundle. You want that burst of energy to carry into the next song and into FOMO if they don't win that gets them visiting the merch table afterward.
Try a hidden ticket under the seat giveaway. Before doors open, tape a small card with your logo and instructions under one or two seats.
Tell the crowd to check under their chair. You will hear the collective gasp when someone finds it. Hand the winner something visible, take a photo, and thank their section for playing.
Grow your list with predictable rhythm and game energy. Once per month, pick one new email subscriber to win a small prize. Announce the winner publicly in your newsletter and on socials.
Don't forget to tell new subscribers they are already in this month’s drawing. That will create goodwill and make them feel like you gave them a cool benefit they didn't have to work for.
At shows, use a QR code for your list and pull a random number at the end of the set from everyone who signed up that night. Announce it from stage during the encore.
That end of show timing matters because it feels like icing on an already delicious cake. The moment becomes shared celebration and it sticks in their memory and generates good brand vibes.
Always capture social proof. If they win live, take a quick photo of you, the fan, and the prize. Post it and tag them. If they win online, ask them to post a selfie with the prize and say you will share it on your channel and in your newsletter.
I know it might feel counterintuitive, but I hope you can see how giving things away for free can actually make you more profitable.
If you want a simple place to start this week, pick one game you can run at your next show and one you can run online. Keep the rules clear. Keep the prize aligned with your brand. Celebrate the winner loudly. Then watch what happens to your energy, your list, and your sales.
Always in your corner,
<3 Bree
You're reading the Profitable Musician, your guide to growing your fanbase, increasing your income and becoming more profitable. Shared with ~16,000+ readers every Wednesday. Was this forwarded to you? Subscribe here so you don't miss the next one.